Custom Cakes · Indianapolis
Made for your
most important moments.
Every custom cake is designed and baked from scratch — for weddings, birthdays, and everything worth celebrating.
Our Work
Built to be remembered.
Every cake is a collaboration. Here’s a look at some of our recent work — weddings, birthdays, and milestones.
Our Custom Cake Process
We believe the best results come from a clear, collaborative process. Here’s what to expect.
1. Consultation
Share your vision, event details, and timeline. We’ll discuss design direction and availability.
2. Design & Proposal
We create a custom design and pricing proposal tailored to your event.
3. Creation & Delivery
Your cake is crafted fresh and delivered or prepared for pickup on your event date.
Pricing
What custom cakes cost.
Standard custom cakes — where you choose the size, flavor, filling, and frosting — are priced per serving and start at $4.50 per serving. Pricing is shown in the online store for each size.
For more elaborate designs, tiered cakes, and wedding cakes, pricing depends on the design, serving count, and time of year. Wedding cakes typically start at $7.00 per serving. Submit an inquiry and we’ll put together a quote within one business day.
Everything is made from scratch — no mixes, no shortcuts. The price reflects that.
Heads Up
We book up fast during peak season.
For weddings and events in June or October, reach out 3–4 months in advance. For custom birthday and celebration cakes, 2 weeks is the minimum. A 50% deposit is required to hold your date — balance due one week before pickup.
Common Questions
Before you reach out.
Online ordering is for our standard custom cakes — you pick the size, cake flavor, filling, and frosting from our available options, and we handle the rest. It’s fast, easy, and available any time.
An inquiry is for anything outside those options — a wedding cake, a tiered cake, a specific design you have in mind, or anything that needs a conversation first. We’ll respond within one business day.
Our standard flavors include vanilla, chocolate, lemon, carrot, red velvet, and almond. Fillings include house buttercream, chocolate ganache, lemon curd, fresh strawberry, and cream cheese. All options are listed in the online store.
We also rotate seasonal flavors throughout the year — ask us what’s current when you order or inquire.
Yes — tastings are available for tiered cake and wedding cake inquiries. They’re by appointment Tuesday through Saturday. We’ll arrange a tasting as part of the inquiry process once we’ve had an initial conversation about your order.
Absolutely — and we encourage it. Photos from Pinterest, Instagram, or other bakeries give us a great starting point. You can attach images when you submit your inquiry. We’ll let you know what’s possible and suggest alternatives where needed.
For online orders, we need at least 48 hours notice for cancellations or changes. Call us at (317) 555-0187.
For inquiry-based orders, cancellations made more than 2 weeks before your pickup date receive a full deposit refund. Cancellations within 2 weeks of the date forfeit the deposit.
Local delivery is available for wedding cakes and large tiered orders within the Indianapolis area. Delivery fees vary by location and are quoted when you place your order. All standard online orders are pickup only from our College Ave location.
Open Tuesday through Sunday.
Tue–Sat 6:30am–6pm | Sun 7am–2pm · 5614 N College Ave, Indianapolis
Get Directions